'Melencolia I' speaks to us in the language of visual allegory. It bristles with motifs and symbols, some of which represent precise ideas, while others resonate with ungraspable significance. In the foreground, a sluggish figure sits on a stone slab in front of a section of wall and stares into space. With her face slumped in her hand (the conventional pose of the melancholic) and her magnificent wings folded, she embodies the dark temperament. Her swarthy features also suggest her emotional state. Even the strange setting, featuring an expansive coastal landscape below heavens framed by a lunar rainbow and pierced by a comet, is tellingly nocturnal.
Strewn around the winged figure is an assortment of tools and instruments relating to geometry, architecture and artistry in general. These include a moulder’s form, a plane, a saw, a ruler, nails, the mouth of a bellows and, on the left, an inkpot and pen case, a hammer and a goldsmith’s crucible with tongs. Hanging on the wall are a pair of scales, an hourglass and a bell. The magic square – where each row of four figures adds up to 34 – is often explained as a Jovian talisman. The numbers in the bottom row show the date of the engraving.
The bewildering array of objects depicted in the print is testimony to Dürer’s profound interest in theories of proportion, calculation and measurement, which culminated in his book on geometry published in 1525. The stone octahedron dominating the left side of the composition is an expression of the artist’s sheer delight in creating unusual geometric forms. Geometry (one of the seven liberal arts) represented for Dürer the very foundation of artistic endeavour, a quasi-mystical discipline through which he hoped to approach perfection in his work. It is not insignificant then, that his protagonist should hold a compass prominently in her right hand. ‘The art of measurement’, he wrote, ‘is the correct grounding of all painting’.
Since antiquity, melancholy (from the Greek μέλαν-χολή, melan-chole, literally ‘black bile’) was understood as one of the four cardinal humours, the others being yellow bile, phlegm and blood. These bodily fluids determined an individual’s emotional and physical state: melancholic, choleric, phlegmatic or sanguine. Each of the humours was attuned to one of the four elements, one of the four seasons, and one of the four times of day.
According to Renaissance cosmology – which loved to draw parallels between the ‘microcosm’ of the human organism and the universe – the humoural makeup of an individual was ultimately decided by the planets. Melancholic types, for example, were dominated by the brooding influence of Saturn. Furthermore, they were associated with the element of earth, the season of autumn, the time of evening, the life phase of maturity, and the qualities of cold and dryness. Thus the wreath of medicinal plants crowning the woman’s head in Melencolia I has been interpreted as a curative to the effects of the latter.
The Renaissance Neo-Platonists reassessed melancholy, elevating what had in earlier times been construed as an illness or vice to the level of a divine gift associated with exceptional creative ability. Marsilio Ficino’s 'De vita triplici' (1489) was the foremost text to assert the connection between artistic talent and the saturnine temperament. It is precisely the uneasy affiliation between superior imaginative prowess and melancholy that underlies the significance and novelty of Dürer’s astonishing image, the first to give pictorial expression to the new ideas concerning the nature of artistic genius. For despite its ennobled form, melancholy remained a precarious gift as it could lead to despair and insanity. While it alone inspired the imagination to soar to its greatest heights, it also presented a formidable obstacle to the realisation of creative potential.
ii of 2 states
23.9 x 18.9 cm platemark; 34.0 x 27.0 cm sheet
Signature & date
Signed and dated l.r., [incised plate] "1514/ AD [artist's monogram]".
Tony Gilbert Bequest Fund 2013
Shown in 3 exhibitions
Von Israhel van Meckenem bis Albrecht Dürer: deutsche Graphik 1470-1530 aus Sammlung Graf Maltzan, C.G. Boerner GmbH, Dusseldorf, 02 Feb 1983–20 Feb 1983
European prints and drawings 1500-1900, Art Gallery of New South Wales, Sydney, 30 Aug 2014–02 Nov 2014
Under the Stars, Art Gallery of New South Wales, Sydney, 21 Mar 2020–2021
Joachim IV Freiherr von Maltzahn, 17th century-1982, Prussia, Schloss Militsch, in Lower Silesia, near Breslau (nowadays Poland). The Counts of Maltzahn (Maltzan)'s collection of old master prints was among the oldest known to us (Lugt 3024a). The collection was begun by Joachim IV Freiherr von Maltzahn (or his father) and passed by descent to (1863–1921), son of Count August Mortimer von Maltzahn (1823–78). Sold by Count Andreas Maltzahn's grandson in 1982 to C G Boerner, Düsseldorf.
C.G. Boerner GmbH, 1982-1983, Düsseldorf/Germany, Purchased in 1982 from Andreas Maltzahn's grandson. Sold in 1983 probably to Samuel Josefowitz.
Samuel Josefowitz, 1983?-29 Jan 2013, Switzerland, Sold at Christie's New York, 'Albrecht Dürer: Masterpieces from a Private Collection', lot 42 to the AGNSW.
Referenced in 18 publications
Art Gallery of New South Wales, Art Gallery of New South Wales annual report 2012–13, Sydney, 2013, pp 64, 90.
Art Gallery of New South Wales, Art Gallery of New South Wales annual report 2014–15, Sydney, 2015, p 9.
Giulia Bartrum, Albrecht Dürer and his legacy. The graphic work of a Renaissance artist, London, 2002, p 188, no 128.
Campbell Dodgson, Albrecht Dürer, London, 1926, no 73II.
F.W.H. Hollstein, Dutch and Flemish etchings, engravings and woodcuts c.1450-1700, Amsterdam, 1949, vol VII, no 75.
Raymond Klibansky, Erwin Panofsky and Fritz Saxl, Saturn and melancholy: studies in the history of natural philosophy, religion and art, England, 1964, pp 284–402.
Joseph Meder, Dürer Katalog; ein handbuch über Albrecht Dürers Stich, Radierungen, Holzschnitte, deren Zustände, Ausgaben und Wasserzeichen, Vienna, 1932, no 75IIa.
Erwin Panofsky, Albrecht Dürer [2 vols], Princeton, 1943, vol I, pp 156–71, vol II, pp 26–27.
Peter Raissis, Look, 'Early European works on paper', Sydney, Aug 2014, pp 20–23: p 21.
Peter Raissis, Look, 'A reason to be cheerful about melancholy', Sydney, Jul 2013, pp 8–9: p 8, illus p 9.
Peter Raissis, Prints & drawings Europe 1500-1900, Sydney, 2014, p 26, col illus pp 24–25 (detail), 27.
Rainer Schoch, Matthias Mende and Anna Scherbaum, Albrecht Dürer. Das druckgraphische Werk, vol. I, Kupferstiche, Eisenradierungen und Kaltnadelblätter, Munich, 2001, pp 179–84, no 71.
Peter-Klaus Schuster, Melencolia I Dürer’s Denkbild [2 vols], Berlin, 1991.
Peter-Klaus Schuster, Mélancolie: génie et folie en Occident, ‘Melencolia I Dürer et sa postérité’, Paris, 2005, pp 90–104, 138–39.
Walter L Strauss, The complete engravings, etchings and drypoints of Albrecht Dürer, New York, 1962, pp 166–69, no 79.
Adam von Bartsch, Le peintre graveur [21 vols], Vienna, 1803-1821, vol 7, pp 87–89, no 74.
Von Israhel van Meckenem bis Albrecht Dürer: deutsche Graphik 1470-1530 aus Sammlung Graf Maltzan, Dusseldorf, 1983, p 82, no 38, illus np.
Albrecht Dürer: masterpieces from a private collection, New York, 29 Jan 2013, p 56, no 42, illus p 57.