We acknowledge the Gadigal of the Eora Nation, the traditional custodians of the Country on which the Art Gallery of NSW stands.

🛈 In line with NSW Health advice, the Art Gallery is temporarily closed to the public. Stay updated on our social media.

Title

Comparative monument (Shellal)

2014-2017

Artist

Tom Nicholson

Australia

1973 –

Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
Alternate image of Comparative monument (Shellal) by Tom Nicholson
  • Details

    Date
    2014-2017
    Media categories
    Sculpture , Installation , Time-based art
    Materials used
    glass tesserae mosaics, wooden boxes, dual channel digital video, colour, sound
    Dimensions
    duration: 00:6:01 min left channel, 00:13:39 min right channel, aspect ratio: 16:9, display dimensions variable :

    a - mosaic 1, 74.9 x 75.8 x 9.7 cm

    b - mosaic 2, 75.5 x 79.3 x 9.7 cm

    c - mosaic 3, 73.5 x 80.5 x 9.8 cm

    d - mosaic 4, 74.3 x 76 x 9.8 cm

    e - mosaic 5, 75.6 x 80.8 x 9.7 cm

    f - mosaic 6, 73.5 x 73.5 x 9.8 cm

    g - mosaic 7, 73 x 73 x 9.7 cm

    h - mosaic 8, 72.5 x 74.8 x 9.7 cm

    i - mosaic 9, 75 x 77.7 x 9.7 cm

    j - mosaic 10, 73.9 x 80.5 x 9.7 cm

    k - mosaic 11, 72.6 x 75 x 9.7 cm

    l - mosaic 12, 75.1 x 79.6 x 9.7 cm

    m - mosaic 13, 72 x 80.2 x 9.7 cm

    n - mosaic 14, 73.8 x 74.5 x 9.8 cm

    o - mosaic 15, 73 x 73.5 x 9.8 cm

    p - empty box 1, 135 x 71 x 10 cm

    p2-p7, 79 x 71 x 10 cm

    p8-p14, 73 x 78 x 10 cm

    p15 - empty box 15, 76 x 71 x 10 cm

    p16-p21, 76 x 78 x 10 cm

    p22-p26, 80 x 74 x 10 cm

    p27-p28, 81 x 72 x 10 cm

    p29 - empty box 29, 85 x 72 x 10 cm

    p30 - empty box 30, 76 x 75 x 10 cm

    p31-34, 75 x 73 x 10 cm

    Signature & date

    Signed l.l. Certificate of authenticity, blue ink "Tom Nicholson [signature]". Not dated.

    Credit
    Contemporary Collection Benefactors and Patrick White Fund 2017
    Location
    Not on display
    Accession number
    89.2017.a-r
    Copyright
    © Tom Nicholson

    Reproduction requests

    Artist information
    Tom Nicholson

    Works in the collection

    1

    Share
  • About

    Tom Nicholson often works with historical material to propose new commemorative forms. 'Comparative monument (Shellal)' is the third in a series exploring historical links and contemporary resonances between Australia and Israel/Palestine.

    The work draws on the complex history of the 6th-century Shellal mosaic, which was uncovered in Palestine by Australian soldiers in 1917 and brought to Canberra. Eventually the mosaic was built into the architecture of the Australian War Memorial (AWM), where it remains. As an act of speculative repatriation, Nicholson has reconstituted the surviving fragments as though using tiles from the vast dome mosaic by Napier Waller in the AWM's Hall of Memory.

    Crated in readiness for its return, 'Comparative monument (Shellal)' invokes the contested sovereignty of the site the original mosaic was taken from. Historically this was located within the territory of Palestine; now it is part of Israel. Today, this desert hilltop offers a view towards Gaza City in one direction and the Israeli city of Bir Sab'a/Be'er Sheva/Beersheba in the other. Nicholson imagines his repatriated mosaic as a platform for this view, which uniquely links the two cities and implies a future alternative to the present.

  • Exhibition history

    Shown in 3 exhibitions

  • Bibliography

    Referenced in 6 publications