We acknowledge the Gadigal of the Eora Nation, the traditional custodians of the Country on which the Art Gallery of NSW stands.


Ibrahim Mahjid – Manus Island, from the series Remain



Hoda Afshar

Iran, Australia

1983 –

  • Details

    Media category
    Materials used
    inkjet archival print
    100.0 x 83.0 cm image; 101.0 x 83.6 x 5.5 cm frame
    Signature & date

    Not signed. Not dated.

    Contemporary Collection Benefactors Fund 2020
    Not on display
    Accession number
    © Hoda Afshar

    Reproduction requests

    Artist information
    Hoda Afshar

    Works in the collection


  • About

    Hoda Afshar’s 2018 body of work 'Remain' is an unflinchingly political commentary on Australia’s border protection policy and serves as testimony to its assault of human rights. Encompassing a film and a suite of photographic portraits, 'Remain' speaks the stories of a group of stateless men who remained on Manus Island, Papua New Guinea, after the immigration detention centre closed in October 2017. In the film, their experiences are recounted as episodic fragments shot through with violence in voice overs that are by turns lyrical and brutal. Some recite poetry, some sing, some remember the riots and the suicides. As their stories unfold, the camera pans over a picturesque landscape – lush foliage and crystal-clear water. A ‘green hell’ as one man describes it. It is the abrupt collision of these two registers, the haunting narrative and the idyllic imagery, that carries the emotional force of the work. It is beautiful and horrifying at the same time.

    The accompanying photographic portraits of the same protagonists are insistent and powerful. They stand before us, in the foreground of the image, against a dark backdrop. In these photographs, there is nothing to distract us from the figures themselves. Nothing to detract from the simple fact of their presence. They each assert their right to be seen. The bluntness of this gesture is itself a political act. For that is what detention does; it makes individuals invisible. In these portraits, Afshar acknowledges the plight of these men metaphorically. They are beset by the elements, by fire, water and earth. But at no point is their humanity questioned.

Other works by Hoda Afshar

See all 17 works