Mothers reply 1976, from the series Scarred for life II
Australia, United States of America
12 Nov 1960 -
‘Scarred for life I’ and ‘II’ are printed on thin off-white paper akin to scaled up pages from ‘Life’ magazine. The first series is of nine images, the second ten images. Originally designed to be pinned to the wall like street posters, Moffatt used photolithography (which was the most common form of printing used in newspapers and magazines in the 19th and 20th centuries) to print the works in faded colours, adding to their ephemeral effect. While ‘Life’ magazine in the 1950s and 1960s published photo-essays on major world events and presented different cultures to its primarily American audience, Moffatt takes the small yet traumatic humiliations of daily life – the sniping and jibing at difference, the feelings of inadequacy which may indeed scar us for life – and makes these stories equivalent in power.
‘Scarred for life’ is set in environments the very ordinariness of which contributes to the dramatic tension. Each suburban drama of familial slighting is at once horrifying as much as it is amusing because of its very mundanity. The viewer recognises similar events from their own past, or strange events that they have witnessed and not quite understood. Most of the tableaux take the point of view corresponding to or mirroring the wounded subject. It is this wounding and lack of resolution which then binds the viewer of the work to the viewer of the event described.
‘Scarred for life I’ and ‘II ‘are unusual in Moffatt’s oeuvre because of the captions. While the words are compelling, they don’t explain the images, indeed they tend to add to their enigmatic nature as though more information is a further dead end. This works directly against the received notion of photographic captioning as necessarily directing understanding. In ‘Scarred for life’ the intricate webs of thought, action, word and image capturing the chasm of ongoing trauma are presented. Moffatt has said that this series may be a continuing project as ‘everyone has a tragic tale to tell’.1
1. Tracey Moffatt interviewed by M Cathcart, 'Arts Today', ABC Radio National, Sydney, 31 Jul 2000
© Art Gallery of New South Wales Photography Collection Handbook, 2007
80.0 x 60.0 cm sheet; 84.5 x 64.5 x 4.5 cm frame
Signature & date
Not signed. Not dated.
Purchased with funds provided by the Photography Collection Benefactors' Program 2000
© Tracey Moffatt. Courtesy of Roslyn Oxley9 Gallery, Sydney
Shown in 1 exhibition
Shadow Catchers, Art Gallery of New South Wales, Sydney, 22 Feb 2020–17 May 2020
Referenced in 3 publications
George Alexander, Photography: Art Gallery of New South Wales Collection, 'Tableaux - memento mori - screen culture', pg.313-335, Sydney, 2007, 318.
Laura Pia, Look, 'Tracey Moffatt: On the subject of Alfred Stieglitz and Prince...", pg. 25-27, Sydney, Aug 2010, 25 (colour illus.), 26.
Jill Sykes (Editor), Look, 'Focusing on the camera, the art of building the Gallery's photography collection', pg.13, Sydney, Mar 2002, 13.